I do not claim to be an expert at reviewing academic papers, but I have done my share of work. Here is my recipe:
Reproducibility, (self-)plagiarism and presentation are easy to evaluate and I usually spend quite a bit of time on these issues. Science should be reproducible. (Panos Ipeirotis seems…
If you are running MacOS and use the Safari browser, I suggest you have a look at Shiira. It uses the same underlying engine (WebKit), but provides a superior skin.
Stephen Downes prepared a Montreal photo set. The photo set is worth a visit if you want to know what Montreal feels like.
I am the nerdiest of the two:
Since I moved to the Montreal suburbs, I have become an active gardener. I used to apply generous amounts of fertilizers. I also got into serious trouble. My lawn died. Not because I burned it, but because I got a bad case of grubs. Several of my perennials died also or fail to come back healthy…
Since I have had amazing luck in the past with questions to the readers of this blog, I have another question.
The diameter of a graph is the longest distance between any two nodes. The degree of a node is the number of edges or links from and to this node.
Intuitively, the higher the node degrees,…
In academic circles, there are intense platform wars. We have a talk next week from the head librarian about offering Google-like services, but on an academic platform. I won’t go to the talk because I no longer care about library portals. Regarding courseware, there are wars between Moodle and…
In the past, I have had luck with my requests for help, so here is another one.
Suppose you have a large array made of a large number of distinct values ({A,B,A,B,A,C,C}) and you want to group the identical values like so {A,A,A,B,B,C,C} or like so {C,C, A,A,A,B,B}. That is, you do not care about…
I am not a neat guy. I tend to drop coffee cups on my desk and I never look back. What I learned this year is that if you leave a cup of cappucino for a week on your desk, then drink a shot of it by mistake while staring at your computer screen, you are left with a terrible taste in your mouth for…
As a young Ph.D. student, I thought that my thesis supervisors were annoying. Looking back, ten years later, I think they were not nearly harsh enough.
I used to think that keeping detailed logs of what I have done was pedantic. As a young researcher or developer, I would just quickly jot down my…
Scientists often cheat. Bad and famous scientists cheat. The cheating can be small or large: putting your name as an author on a paper that you barely read, omitting part of the an experiment, making up experimental results, claiming that you have a proof of a given result, making something look…
We are looking for someone to fill a permanent position as an education specialist (spécialiste en sciences de l’éducation). The job includes some research time. You must have a degree in education, or the equivalent. Some of our specialists have Ph.D.s. Some training in Computer Science would…
Back when I was a Mathematics undergraduate student at the University of Toronto, I was told by some of my peers that I was not a Mathematician but a problem solver. This was meant as a derogatory remark, but I thought it was a correct assessment. In short, I cared only about a given theorem if it…
This year, I am the course coordinator for a Java course. One of our tutors went missing. Human resources tried to negotiate with him but he told them he did not care anymore.
I googled him. I got his resume, and then noticed that the top line says “2008: now with Google.”
I guess that must be…
Yesterday, I wrote about the types of collaboration we commonly observe in science. Today, I want to spend 5 minutes thinking about what happens when you write a science paper alone.
Benefits:
New projects can emerge and die quickly.
You set your own standards.
You increase your range of skills by…
Scientists collaborate frequently. Most science articles have at least two authors.
Some collaborations work well, others fail. The first step to understanding what went wrong is to categorize the collaboration. I distinguish three types:
Hierarchical collaboration: the student collaborates with…