Daniel Lemire's blog

, 2 min read

A sample paper review

4 thoughts on “A sample paper review”

  1. Unfortunately, I believe this was a true review, and I got worse reviews that this one.

    We have to collectively stand up and complain when we get such bad reviews.

  2. Yuhong YAN says:

    :))) That is the collection of all worest judgement you can get. Somtimes a loser researcher can do this.

  3. Anon says:

    im so used to receiving such reviews that I’ve probably written a few like that by now 🙂

    just kidding.

  4. Pasya says:

    Yes, I’ve seen such reviews in my short and multiple-stop career as a research student. I wonder what purpose do they serve, except the one that mandates the PC to kick out some papers, so that the acceptance rates remain “low”.